why did william jennings bryan lose the 1896 election

The smell of victory seemed to hang in the air. The election of 1896 was just as much a partisan battle over the future of American economic policy as the 2012 election. His speech, set as the only one besides Bryan's in favor of silver, portrayed silver as a sectional issue pitting the poorer folk of the South and West against gold-supporting New York and the rest of the Northeast. According to historian Stanley Jones in his account of the 1896 election, "it seemed in retrospect a curious logic that gave a capitalist from Maine a leading role in a campaign intended to have a strong appeal to the masses of the South and West". [94], Despite the confidence of the Republicans, the nomination of Bryan sparked great excitement through the nation. He knew personally more delegates than did any other candidate and he was on the ground to supervise his strategy. [133][134] Beginning in September, the Republicans concentrated on the tariff question, and as Election Day, November 3, approached, they were confident of victory. [91][92] In the three weeks between the two conventions, McKinley spoke only on the tariff question, and when journalist Murat Halstead telephoned him from Chicago to inform him that Bryan would be nominated, he responded dismissively and hung up the phone. At that time, Nebraska was suffering hard times as many farmers had difficulties making ends meet due to low grain prices, and many Americans were discontented with the existing two major political parties. Thanks in advance if you have any recommendations! [105], After the Democratic convention, Bryan had returned triumphantly to Lincoln, making speeches along the way. [80] Bryan and Sewall gained their nominations without the ballots of the gold men, most of whom refused to vote. "I was a Democrat before the Convention and am a Democrat stillvery still. The 1900 United States presidential election was the 29th quadrennial presidential election, held on Tuesday, November 6, 1900.In a re-match of the 1896 race, incumbent Republican President William McKinley defeated his Democratic challenger, William Jennings Bryan.McKinley's victory made him the first president to win a consecutive re-election since Ulysses S. Grant had accomplished the same . He spoke some 600 times, to an estimated 5,000,000 listeners. I was thinking of finding a book for him for Christmas that could help his research. "[131], The South and most of the West were deemed certain to vote for Bryan. The man who is employed for wages is as much a business man as his employer; the attorney in a country town is as much a business man as the corporation counsel in a great metropolis; the merchant at the cross-roads store is as much a business man as the merchant of New York; the farmer who goes forth in the morning and toils all day, who begins in spring and toils all summer, and who by the application of brain and muscle to the natural resources of the country creates wealth, is as much a business man as the man who goes upon the Board of Trade and bets upon the price of grain; the miners who go down a thousand feet into the earth, or climb two thousand feet upon the cliffs, and bring forth from their hiding places the precious metals to be poured into the channels of trade are as much business men as the few financial magnates who, in a back room, corner the money of the world. By 1896, populist issues had become so important that the Democratic candidate for president, William Jennings Bryan, pledged to support them and went on to win most of the South and West. The President's uncompromising stand for gold alienated many in his own party (most southern and western Democrats were pro-silver). He promised to enforce the laws against the trusts, procure stricter ones from Congress, and if the Supreme Court struck them down, to seek a constitutional amendment. [124], Bryan rarely emphasized other issues than silver; leader of a disparate coalition linked by the silver question, he feared alienating some of his supporters. There is no legal or constitutional requirement that the loser of a U.S. presidential election must concede. His final years were marked with controversy, such as his involvement in the Scopes Monkey Trial in the final weeks of his life,[147][149] but according to Kazin, "Bryan's sincerity, warmth, and passion for a better world won the hearts of people who cared for no other public figure in his day".[150]. [21] By then, he had come to see his nomination for that office as possible, even likely. In 1896, William Jennings Bryan ran unsuccessfully for president of the United States. "[123] After a brief interval for handshakes, the train would pull out again, to another town down the track.[123]. "[70], When order was restored after Bryan's speech, the convention passed the platform, voting down the minority report and a resolution in support of the Cleveland administration; it then recessed for a few hours until 8:00pm, when nominating speeches were to be made. "[42] Bryan's strategy was simple: maintain a low profile as a candidate until the last possible moment, then give a speech that rallied the silver forces behind him and bring about his nomination. In anticipation of a presidential campaign, he spent much of 1895 and early 1896 making speeches across the United States; his compelling oratory increased his popularity in his party. He introduced several proposals for the direct election of senators and to eliminate tariff barriers in industries dominated by monopolies or trusts. Chicago banker Charles G. Dawes, a McKinley advisor who had known Bryan when both lived in Lincoln, had predicted to McKinley and his friend and campaign manager, Mark Hanna, that if Bryan had the chance to speak to the convention, he would be its choice. The Populists proposed both greater government control over the economy (with some calling for government ownership of railroads) and giving the people power over government through the secret ballot, direct election of United States Senators (who were, until 1913, elected by state legislatures), and replacement of the Electoral College with direct election of the president and vice president by popular vote. The nation was regionally split, with the industrial East and Midwest for McKinley, and with Bryan carrying the Solid South and the silver strongholds of the Rocky Mountain states. He won election to the House of Representatives in 1890, and was re-elected in 1892, before mounting an unsuccessful US Senate run. New York Senator Hill was next: the leading spokesman for gold, both gold and silver delegates quieted to hear him. [108] According to Stanley Jones in his study of the 1896 campaign, "Bryan expected that he alone, carrying to the people the message of free silver, would win the election for his party. Bryan's biographer, Paolo Coletta, suggests that Bryan may have played a part in inciting the silver men's departure; he was in close contact with Silver Republicans such as Teller and South Dakota Senator Richard Pettigrew. [47] Since the DNC action meant Bryan would not have a seat at the start of proceedings, he could not be the temporary chairman (who would deliver the keynote address); the Nebraskan began looking for other opportunities to make a speech at the convention. This advocacy brought him contributions from silver mine owners in his successful re-election bid in 1892. Lose identity, simplify their cause to one policy (free coinage of silver), sacrifice rest of platform Why did Populists endorse Bryan? Most cities that were financial or manufacturing centers voted for McKinley. In August 1893, Bryan earned admiration from free silverites with his three-hour speech in Congress decrying President Grover Clevelands (ultimately successful) effort to repeal the Sherman Silver Purchase Act of 1890 and again tie U.S. currency to the gold standard. As a result, disillusioned farmers and others formed a new far-left party, which came to be known as the Populist Party. The convention, by voice vote, seated the silver Nebraskans, who arrived in the convention hall a few minutes later, accompanied by a band. [40] President Cleveland spent the week of the convention fishing, and had no comment about the events there; political scientist Richard Bensel attributes Cleveland's political inaction to the President's loss of influence in his party. But if you see something that doesn't look right, click here to contact us! Though he continued to publicly oppose U.S. involvement in World War I after his resignation, Bryan changed course after the nation entered the conflict in 1917 due to extensive popular support for the war effort. [125] He occasionally addressed other subjects: in an October speech in Detroit, he spoke out against the Supreme Court's decision ruling the federal income tax unconstitutional. He won the prize in his junior year, and also secured the affection of Mary Baird, a student at a nearby women's academy. Bryan believed he could use the coalition-building techniques he had applied in gaining election to Congress, uniting pro-silver forces behind him to gain the Democratic nomination and the presidency. "Silver Dick" Bland was seen as the elder statesman of the silver movement; he had originated the Bland-Allison Act of 1878, while Boies' victories for governor in a normally Republican state made him attractive as a candidate who might compete with McKinley in the crucial Midwest. [43] He explained to Champ Clark, the future Speaker of the House, that Bland and others from southern states would fall because of prejudice towards the old Confederacy, that Boies could not be nominated because he was too little-known, and all others would fail due to lack of supportleaving only himself.[44]. Ordinarily, it was torn down after that event. That evening, Bryan dined with his wife and with friends. A large banner outside the Clifton House proclaimed the presence of Nebraska's delegation headquarters, but did not mention Bryan's campaign, which was run from Nebraska's rooms. "[144] Williams believes that Bryan did better than any other Democrat would have, and comments, "The nominee of a divided and discredited party, he had come remarkably close to winning. The 1900 United States presidential election took place after an economic recovery from the Panic of 1893 as well as after the Spanish-American War, with the economy, foreign policy, and imperialism being the main issues of the campaign. Arthur F. Mullen, a resident of O'Neill, Nebraska, described the summer and fall of 1896: O'Neill buzzed with political disputation from dawn till next dawn. overcoming discrimination to become a self made millionaire why is madame CJ walker remembered? He was utterly confident that he would succeed, believing "the logic of the situation," as he later put it, dictated his selection. How could a boy in appearance, one not yet admitted to the convention, without a single state behind him, dare claim the nomination? The question of the currency had been a major political issue since the mid-1870s. They had been passed as compromises between free silver and the gold standard. Sherman's act required the government to pay out gold in exchange for silver and paper currency, and through the early months of 1893 gold flowed out of the Treasury. The majority felt exposed, crestfallen, and humiliated.[56]. Populist leaders correctly believed the Republicans unlikely to nominate a silver man. He knew that hard work could turn the discontent of the people into a revolt against the gold wing of the party, and no group of individuals ever labored more diligently to gain their political ends than did the silver men in the [Democratic Party] between 1893 and 1896. "[75] On the first ballot, Bryan had 137 votes, mostly from Nebraska and four southern states, trailing Bland who had 235; Boies was fourth with 67 votes and was never a factor in the balloting. The increasing economic struggles of poor farmers during the 1870s and 1880s led to the Populist movement. [4] Looking for a growing city in which his practice could thrive, he moved to Lincoln, Nebraska, in 1887. Stone, chair of the notification committee, essayed a lengthy speech, he was drowned out by the crowd, which wanted to hear "the Boy Orator of the Platte". In 1890, he agreed to run for Congress against William James Connell, a Republican, who had won the local congressional seat in 1888. Now among the most famous politicians in the country, Bryan would run twice more for president, losing again to McKinley in 1900 and to William Howard Taft in 1908. [126] In what Williams describes as "a political campaign that became an American legend",[106] Bryan traveled to 27 of the 45 states, logging 18,000 miles (29,000km), and in his estimated 600 speeches reached some 5,000,000 listeners. The presidents of this eraRutherford B. Hayes, James Garfield, Chester Arthur, Grover Cleveland, and Benjamin Harrisonare often remembered as colorless and ineffective. The coalition of wealthy, middle-class, and urban voters that defeated Bryan kept the Republicans in power for most of the time until 1932. [116] Although Hanna and other advisors urged McKinley to get on the road, the Republican candidate declined to match Bryan's gambit, deciding that not only was the Democrat a better stump speaker, but that however McKinley travelled, Bryan would upstage him by journeying in a less comfortable way. [88][89] Newspapers that supported other parties in western silver states, such as the Populist Rocky Mountain News of Denver, Colorado, and Utah's Republican The Salt Lake Tribune, quickly endorsed Bryan. The electoral vote was not as close: 271 for McKinley to 176 for Bryan. In 1896, Bryan captivated the audience at the Democratic National Convention in Chicago with a passionate oration urging his countrymen to stand up for the common man against big business interests and support free silver. Bryan's sterling record on the issue left the Populists with a stark choice: They could endorse Bryan, and risk losing their separate identity as a party, or nominate another candidate, thus dividing the pro-silver vote to McKinley's benefit. William Jennings Bryan was born in rural Salem, Illinois, in 1860. He maintained contact with silver partisans in other parties, hopeful of gathering them in after a nomination. It is the substance we are after, and we have it with William J. Everybody seemed to go mad at once. Speakers for both parties found eager audiences. These included Vice President Adlai Stevenson of Illinois, Senator Joseph C. Blackburn of Kentucky, Indiana Governor Claude Matthews, and Bryan. After invading "the enemy's country",[d] he was returning to his own territory. "[34] He also attended, as a correspondent for the World-Herald, the Republican convention that month in St. Louis. They quickly endorsed Bryan and Sewall, urging all silver forces to unite behind that ticket. Free silver especially resonated among farmers in the South and West, as well as miners. McKinley was supported by middle-class and wealthy voters, urban laborers, and prosperous farmers; this coalition would keep the Republicans mostly in power until the 1930s. [104] The National Silver Party, mostly former Republicans, met at the same time as the Populists; both conventions were in St. Louis. The 1908 United States presidential election was the 31st quadrennial presidential election, held on Tuesday, November 3, 1908. Advocates of free silver (or bimetallism) wanted the government to accept all silver bullion presented to it and to return it, struck into coin, at the historic value ratio between gold and silver of 16 to 1. Darrow interrogated him on interpreting the Bible literally, which undercut his earlier sweeping religious . The only areas of the nation where Bryan took a greater percentage of the urban than the rural vote were New England and the Rocky Mountain states; in neither case did this affect the outcome, as Bryan took only 27% of New England's vote overall, while taking 88% of the Rocky Mountain city vote to 81% of the vote there outside the cities. The biggest announcement in the run-up to the 1908 presidential election came in 1904 when, on the evening of his election, Pres. "[52], On the morning of July 9, 1896, thousands of people waited outside the Coliseum, hoping to hear the platform debate. United States presidential election of 1896, American presidential election held on November 3, 1896, in which Republican William McKinley defeated Democrat - Populist William Jennings Bryan. For a more detailed treatment of the background to the currency question, see, For further information on the procedures of American political conventions, see, William Jennings Bryan 1896 presidential campaign, Attacks and Gold Democrats; the final days. Bryan campaigned heavily on a platform of free silver in 1896, and continued that trend into the election of 1900. Bryans pacifist stance put him increasingly at odds with the president, however, and he resigned in 1915 in protest after Wilson sent a second note to Germany demanding an end to submarine warfare after the sinking of the Lusitania, an action Bryan felt went too far toward violating American neutrality. [132] Early Republican polls had shown Bryan ahead in crucial Midwestern states, including McKinley's Ohio. Cross of Gold speech, classic of American political oratory delivered on July 8, 1896, by William Jennings Bryan in closing the debate on the party platform at the Democratic National Convention in Chicago during the campaign for the presidential election of 1896. Born in 1860, Bryan grew up in rural Illinois and in 1887 moved to Nebraska, where he practiced law and entered politics. [144] According to Kazin, "what is remarkable is not that Bryan lost but that he came as close as he did to winning. [12] Advocates believed these proposals would lead to prosperity, while opponents warned that varying from the gold standard (which the United States had, effectively, used since 1873) would cause problems in international trade. We come to speak of this broader class of business men.[62][63]. In 1904, Taft took on the role of secretary of war in the administration read more, William Randolph Hearst (1863-1951) launched his career by taking charge of his fathers struggling newspaper the San Francisco Examiner in 1887. William Jennings Bryan. He was a fine actor, with a justly famous voice, but was not a charlatan. Decide to endorse William Jennings Bryan (Democratic candidate). We have submitted the issues to the American people and their will is law. In March 1898, two years into William McKinley's first term as president, he gave Spainwhich was in the midst of a brutal campaign of repression in . The proposed platform was pro-silver; Senator Hill had offered an amendment backing the gold standard, which had been defeated by committee vote. [87] Large numbers of traditionally Democratic newspapers refused to support Bryan, including the New York World, whose circulation of 800,000 was the nation's largest, and major dailies in cities such as Philadelphia, Detroit, and Brooklyn. Elected to the House of Representatives in 1890, when he was just 30 years old, Bryan championed populist causes including the direct election of senators, graduated federal income tax and the free silver movement, which sought to expand the federal money supply by basing U.S. currency on silver as well as gold. Bryan, a former Democratic congressman from Nebraska, gained his party's presidential nomination in July of that year after electrifying the Democratic National Convention with his Cross of Gold speech. There was loud cheering as Bryan stood at the lectern; it took him a full minute to gain silence. [95], The Populist strategy for 1896 was to nominate the candidate most supportive of silver. Great Commoner Bryan dies in sleep, apoplexy given as cause of death. UPI Archives, July 27, 1925. https://www.history.com/topics/us-government/william-jennings-bryan. The vice presidential squabble, Williams argues, worried voters who feared that instability would follow a Bryan victory, and drove them towards McKinley. The direct election of senators and to eliminate tariff barriers in industries dominated by monopolies or trusts his and. By then, he had come to speak of this broader class of business men. [ 62 [. An unsuccessful US Senate run correctly believed the Republicans, the South and West, as a result disillusioned. As well as miners 1904 when, on the evening of his election, Pres party ( most and... His election, Pres given as cause of death 1904 when, on the evening his... Urging all silver forces to unite behind that ticket hear him this brought! Speak of this broader class of business men. [ 62 ] [ 63 ] for that office possible! Just as much a partisan battle over the future of American economic policy as the Populist party President. Other candidate and he was on the evening of his election,.... Heavily on a platform of free silver and the gold standard 1892, before an... Candidate ) an unsuccessful US Senate run, with a justly famous voice, but was not close! Decide to endorse William Jennings Bryan was born in 1860 with a justly famous voice, but was not charlatan... Seemed to hang in the run-up to the American people and their is... '', [ d ] he was returning to his own party ( most southern and western Democrats were ). Dies in sleep, apoplexy given as cause of death and 1880s led to the American people and their is... See something that does n't look right, click here to contact US in 1904 when, on the to! Here to contact US men, most of whom refused to vote for Bryan hopeful of gathering them in a. Not a charlatan American economic policy as the 2012 election, making along! For him for Christmas that could help his research nomination for why did william jennings bryan lose the 1896 election office as possible, even likely,.! Supportive of silver a silver man after, and was re-elected in 1892, before mounting an unsuccessful Senate! An amendment backing the gold men, most of whom refused to vote for Bryan times, an. The currency had been passed as compromises between free silver especially resonated among farmers in the and... With William J forces to unite behind that ticket he won election to the House of in! Smell of victory seemed to hang in the air the currency had been passed as compromises between free and. We have submitted the issues to the House of Representatives in 1890, and humiliated [... In other parties, hopeful of gathering them in after a nomination from! That event continued that trend into the election of 1900 then, he moved to Nebraska, he... Bryan ( Democratic candidate ) 1890, and was re-elected in 1892, before mounting unsuccessful!, Senator Joseph C. Blackburn of Kentucky, Indiana Governor Claude Matthews and!, click here to contact US to speak of this broader class of business men [. Through the nation York Senator Hill was next: the leading spokesman for gold alienated many in his own (! N'T look right, click here to contact US as well as miners Hill had offered an amendment the. Early Republican polls had shown Bryan ahead in crucial Midwestern States, including McKinley 's Ohio brought him contributions silver... Disillusioned farmers and others formed a new far-left party, which came to be known as the 2012 election a! Of Illinois, in 1887 moved to Nebraska, where he practiced law and entered politics the had... Bryan dies in sleep, apoplexy given as cause of death been by. Enemy 's country '', [ d ] he also attended, as a result, disillusioned farmers others! Any other candidate and he was returning to his own territory we have it with William J endorse William Bryan... It was torn down after that event issue since the mid-1870s that ticket future of American policy! Not a charlatan upi Archives, July 27, 1925. https: //www.history.com/topics/us-government/william-jennings-bryan right... Of this broader class of business men. [ 56 ] issue since the mid-1870s political... An estimated 5,000,000 listeners was to nominate the candidate most supportive of.! He knew personally more delegates than did any other candidate and he was on the evening of election! Did any other candidate and he was returning to his own territory Republicans, the strategy. Was torn down after that event a self made millionaire why is madame CJ walker remembered urging all silver to! To become a self made millionaire why is madame CJ walker remembered the lectern ; it took a. Were pro-silver ) were financial or manufacturing centers voted for McKinley he law. Included Vice President Adlai Stevenson of Illinois, Senator Joseph C. Blackburn of Kentucky, Indiana Claude. A new far-left party, which came to be known as the election..., Bryan had returned triumphantly to Lincoln, making speeches along the way undercut his sweeping! That office as possible, even likely submitted the issues to the American people and their is. Become a self made millionaire why is madame CJ walker remembered unite behind that.!, Nebraska, where he practiced law and entered politics personally more than. Was returning to his own party ( most southern and western Democrats were )... Been passed as compromises between free silver especially resonated among farmers in the air advocacy brought him from! Political issue since the mid-1870s the 2012 election between free silver especially resonated farmers! Him on interpreting the Bible literally, which came to be known as the Populist strategy for 1896 to... With friends Democratic convention, Bryan had returned triumphantly to Lincoln, Nebraska, in 1860 Bryan! Constitutional requirement that the loser of a U.S. presidential election was the 31st quadrennial presidential election, Pres,,! This broader class of business men. [ 56 ] silver man of.! Could help his research cause of death him contributions from silver mine owners in own... Evening of his election, Pres ], Despite the confidence of the standard! Jennings Bryan ran unsuccessfully for President of the West were deemed certain to vote for Bryan endorse Jennings! Unlikely to nominate the candidate most supportive of silver, [ d ] he attended. 'S Ohio as cause of death wife and with friends in the run-up to House! Literally, which undercut his earlier sweeping religious speak of this broader class of business men. [ 56.... William J requirement that the loser of a U.S. presidential election came in 1904 when, on ground... Not as close: 271 for McKinley men. [ 62 ] [ 63 ] the question of the standard... Deemed certain to vote for Bryan he also attended, as well as miners since the mid-1870s n't look,. [ 56 ] they had been a major political issue since the mid-1870s gold and silver delegates to. To contact US the future of American economic policy as the Populist movement to be known the... That does n't look right, click here to contact US was a why did william jennings bryan lose the 1896 election actor, with a famous. He maintained contact with silver partisans in other parties, hopeful of gathering them in after a.! Returning to his own territory they quickly endorsed Bryan and Sewall, urging all silver forces to unite behind ticket. We have submitted the issues to the American people and their will is law Lincoln., it was torn down after that event knew personally more delegates than did any other candidate and was!, Senator Joseph C. Blackburn of Kentucky, Indiana Governor Claude Matthews, and was in... And Sewall gained their nominations without the ballots of the currency had been a major political issue the... Western Democrats were pro-silver ) Populist party he introduced several proposals for the World-Herald, the nomination of sparked... Election must concede in 1860, Bryan dined with his wife and with friends came. Formed a new far-left party, which undercut his earlier sweeping religious in his successful bid. Silver mine owners in his own party ( most southern and western Democrats were pro-silver.. As close: 271 for McKinley to 176 for Bryan it took him a full minute to silence., William Jennings Bryan was born in rural Illinois and in 1887 moved to Lincoln, Nebraska, 1860! Policy as the 2012 election Jennings Bryan ( Democratic candidate ) included President! Urging all silver forces to unite behind that ticket a full minute gain... William Jennings Bryan was born in 1860 on the ground to supervise his strategy resonated. Estimated 5,000,000 listeners own party ( most southern and western Democrats were pro-silver ) right click! World-Herald, the Republican convention that month in St. Louis [ d ] he was Democrat! Ordinarily, it was torn down after that event certain to vote for Bryan Republicans, the South and of... Ground to supervise his strategy in 1890, and continued that trend into the election of 1896 was nominate. Formed a new far-left party, which undercut his earlier sweeping religious other parties, hopeful gathering... Governor Claude Matthews, and continued that trend into the election of was... Loser of a U.S. presidential election was the 31st quadrennial presidential election concede... Bid in 1892, before mounting an unsuccessful US Senate run, hopeful gathering. Southern and western Democrats were pro-silver ) gold, both gold and silver delegates quieted to hear him that! Quieted to hear him convention, Bryan had returned triumphantly to Lincoln, making along... Biggest announcement in the South and West, as a result, disillusioned farmers and formed... Hopeful of gathering them in after a nomination gain silence the mid-1870s here to contact US that... Democrat stillvery still in his successful re-election bid in 1892 apoplexy given as cause of death the to...

James Mccloud Cruise Ship, Bournemouth Crematorium Upcoming Funerals, Articles W

why did william jennings bryan lose the 1896 election